Organ donation Consent solution has undesirable side effects according to study
According to a new study, the so-called opt-out solution for organ donation is having unexpected side effects. In countries that have introduced it, the number of deceased donations increased only slightly, while living donations fell significantly.
02.11.2025, 09:31
SDA
With the objection solution adopted in Switzerland in 2022, all persons who have not objected during their lifetime are considered organ donors.
According to a study published in the specialist journal "Pnas Nexus", the number of deceased donors increased by an average of 1.21 per million inhabitants in 24 countries that introduced such a system. At the same time, the number of living donations fell by 4.59 per million inhabitants.
However, Swisstransplant Director Franz Immer warns against jumping to conclusions. The study is "monothematic" and ignores important factors such as trust in the healthcare system, he says. In Switzerland, the extended opt-out solution is not due to come into force until 2027 at the earliest. Immer expects the approval rate to rise from 40 to around 60 percent.
