Foodstuffs Nestlé water scandal: report accuses state of "cover-up"
In the scandal surrounding the illegal treatment of mineral water in France, a report by the French Senate makes serious accusations against the state: there was a deliberate "cover-up" to cover up unlawful practices by food giant Nestlé.
19.05.2025, 11:38
19.05.2025, 15:48
SDA
On the one hand, the report criticizes Nestlé's "lack of transparency". "It went badly", Commission rapporteur Alexandre Ouizille told the media at the hearings of the company's top management. On Monday, he spoke of a "refusal to answer" on the part of the company management.
The report also criticizes the state's behaviour towards the authorities and the public. Almost four years after the first revelations, there is still no complete clarification. The committee was set up in November 2024 after investigations by several media outlets uncovered illegal water treatment.
The story has been dragging on for years. During the investigation, Nestlé admitted that it had discovered at the end of 2020 that prohibited processes were being used at the Perrier, Hépar and Contrex sites. In mid-2021, the company turned to the government and the President.
No legal consequences
18 months later, the authorities approved a plan to replace the banned methods with a controversial microfiltration process. According to experts, however, this could change the properties of natural mineral water - which is not permitted under EU law.
Despite the obvious deception of consumers, there were no legal consequences, according to the report. The balance of power between the state and industry is also criticized: Nestlé had made the approval of microfiltration a condition for the end of illegal practices - ultimately the state had agreed at the highest level.
The report states that the Elysée Palace was closely involved in the case and had been aware of the illegal methods since 2022. Alexis Kohler, Secretary General of the President, personally received Nestlé representatives. President Emmanuel Macron denied any knowledge of this in February.
Nestlé was able to continue marketing the water under the profitable name "natural mineral water". According to the report, there is still a lack of comprehensive monitoring at all production sites. Of a total of 28 recommendations, the Commission particularly emphasizes better control of water withdrawals, comprehensive quality monitoring of groundwater resources and improved labelling.
Nestlé regrets and criticizes
Nestlé "takes note" of the results of the Senate report, as the company stated in a statement. The company emphasized the need for clear, uniform rules for the industry.
At the same time, the company criticized the sometimes "defamatory" accusations made against representatives and employees in the context of the investigation. The company reiterated its regret about earlier, now discontinued, irregular practices and assured that it would continue to cooperate fully with the judiciary.
At the same time, Nestlé referred to the safety of its products, which has been confirmed by government agencies and the Commission, and warned against political statements that fuel uncertainty. According to the company, contacts with the authorities have always been conducted transparently and in accordance with the rules. Nestlé also emphasized a long-term commitment to the protection of water resources, which was also highlighted in the report.
Perrier under observation
The Perrier brand is currently under observation: the authorization to use the spring as "natural mineral water" is in question. State-commissioned hydrogeologists have already issued a negative verdict. The responsible prefecture wants to make a decision by August 7 and has asked Nestlé to stop microfiltration within two months. According to the authorities, this changes the microbial profile of the water - a violation of current regulations. Nestlé announced that it would propose alternative solutions.
The French market for mineral and spring water comprises around 104 locations, 11,000 jobs and an annual turnover of 3 billion euros. A government report had already revealed in 2022 that around 30 percent of water brands use unauthorized treatments.
Nestlé CEO expresses regret
In March, Nestlé CEO Laurent Freixe had to justify himself to the Senate. He had expressed his regret to the committee. "On behalf of the Nestlé Group, I would once again like to express my deepest regret about this situation in the past, which was not in line with the values of our Group," he said. Nestlé Waters had done everything possible to put an end to the practices in question.
According to recent media reports, the company is now considering the sale of its water division. In November 2024, the company itself announced a review of its strategy for the water business, including partnerships.
